Feminist Standpoint Theory Revisited. Susan Hekman. I N , THE PUBLICATION of Nancy Hartsock. Sex, and Power changed the landscape of feminist theo. Feminist standpoint theory, then, makes a contribution to epistemology, within a number of disciplines—such as Dorothy Smith, Nancy Hartsock, Hilary Rose. Reviewing Hartsock: The Feminist Standpoint: Toward a Specifically Feminist Historical Materialism. Hartsock looks to answer the general.

Author: Faumi Kesho
Country: Botswana
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Music
Published (Last): 8 August 2011
Pages: 181
PDF File Size: 18.16 Mb
ePub File Size: 17.77 Mb
ISBN: 490-2-65120-938-3
Downloads: 70665
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Bale

Jaggar – – In Sandra G. Yet standpoint theory remains controversial and its controversies manifest both between and beyond feminist scholars, as Alison Wylie writes. The charge that feminist standpoint epistemologies feminiwt committed to a politically dangerous epistemic relativism ensues from tue claim that all knowledge is socially situated and that some social values enhance the process of enquiry and the acquisition of knowledge.

More than three decades have passed since the publication of the first work that developed and advocated feminist standpoint theories. Living as we did—on the edge—we hzrtsock a particular way of seeing reality. This need for struggle emphasizes the hhartsock that a feminist standpoint is not something that anyone can have simply by claiming it.

Posted by Hazelsapien at 4: Feminist standpoint theorists make three principal claims: However, workers are immersed in this world only standloint the time in which their labour power is purchased i. Here feminist standpoint theory is examined primarily as a feminist epistemology and as a methodology for feminist researchers in the social sciences where, arguably, feminist standpoint theory has had the most influence and been the subject of most debate.

Thus some women professionals emphasize only those characteristics considered valuable in their professional context, allowing themselves to be women and feminist only in private contexts. Women and workers are similar in many ways emphasis on change — not statis; characterized by interaction with natural substances — not separation femlnist nature; emphasis on quality, unification of the and body in performed activities, etc.

On the other hand, others view this concept as problematic and stereotypical towards males as it makes all men seem like they are constantly trying to take control and that they seem like they know more than women do. It is against a background of a standard such as this that it would be possible to claim, without retreat to relativism, that marginalized standpoints can offer epistemic advantage.

Standpoints make visible hartsick of social relations and feminust the natural world that are unavailable from dominant perspectives, and in so doing they generate the kinds of questions that will lead to a more complete and true account of those relations.


There has been agreement between feminist standpoint theorists that a standpoint is not just a perspective that is occupied simply by the fact of being a woman.

On the flipside of this, men are less responsible and therefore less aware of subsistence activity. Journal of Women in Culture and Society.

The Feminist Standpoint

Only when we are socially located in certain respects, Kukla argues, can we best perceive certain aspects of reality. The experience of person A is of the entrance to a building. Feminist epistemology does not adopt a monolithic critical position with respect to a traditional canon of epistemological work; rather it consists of a variety of feminist epistemological approaches, of which feminist standpoint epistemologies form a strand.

It is no historical accident that feminist standpoint theory emerged in academic discourses more or less contemporaneously with the feminist consciousness movement within feminist activism.

Thee standpoint differs in this respect from a perspective, which anyone can have simply by ‘opening one’s eyes. Geminist to all these standpoint theories are feminist analyses and critiques of relations between material experience, power, and epistemology, and of the effects of power relations on the production of knowledge.

At first blush there appears a tension between the traditional epistemological assumption that a general, universal and abstract account of knowledge and scientific enquiry is possible, and the politically inflected feminist claim that such analyses are only properly understood in the social contexts in which they arise, and in terms of the biases and prejudices those contexts generate. Ethnic and Racial Studies. Black feminist standpoint argues that the knowledge gained about an individual or other groups in society is gained from multiple factors related to their historical position in society.

Boys cleanly resolve this crisis, whereas girls are much more likely to retain both parents as love objects. Dorothy Smithteaching at University of California, Berkeley when stanpoint women’s movement was in its early stages, looked at the experience of female academics and began to ask about life stories of these women.

By portraying African-American women as self-defined, self-reliant individuals confronting race, gender, and class oppression, Afrocentric feminist thought speaks to the importance that knowledge plays in empowering oppressed people. Black feminist thought describes black women as a unique group that exists in a “place” in US social relations where intersectional processes of race, ethnicity, gender, class, and sexual orientation shape black women’s individual and collective consciousness, standpoinh, and actions.

Standpoint feminist theorists attempt to criticize dominant conventional epistemologies in the social and natural sciences, as well as defend the coherence of feminist knowledge. The ideal, the abstract, and the social is a world that has been idealized as above the body, material, and biological, and has been aligned with the masculine realm O.


Science and Values in General Philosophy of Science. Joseph Rouse says, “The first lesson suggested by standpoint theories has not been sufficiently emphasized in the literature. Monday, January 13, Reviewing Hartsock: Feminist movements and ideologies Feminist theory Feminism and society Feminism and social class Feminism and history.

Hartsoc, theorists such as Donna Haraway sought to show standpoint as the “notion of situated knowledge Newer Post Older Post Home. Oxford University Press, b. Rollins, meanwhile, argues that the bias paradox arises out of a foundationalist framework: A concise glossary of feminist theory. Standpoint theories remind us why a naturalistic conception of knowing is so important. Sandra Harding – – Hypatia 24 4: According to feminist standpoint theories, the process of achieving knowledge begins when standpoints begin to emerge.

Hirschmann – – Cornell University Press.

Standpoint feminism – Wikipedia

Hartsock looks to answer the general question of to what extent gender is a world-view structuring experience. Feminists have just begin to unravel the female experience, searching for commonalities across diverse experiences of women, and are struggling to identify the structural determinants of these experiences.

Menstruation, coitus, pregnancy, childbirth, lactation, all represent challenges to bodily boundaries. Hartsock posits that division of labour is just that, but when the sexual division of labour occurs, we can see oppositions and differences, which have consequences for the epistemology of that society, and leads to deeper structuring forces which lead to inequalities.

One distinguishing feature of Black feminist thought is its insistence that both the changed consciousness of individuals and the social transformation of political and economic institutions constitute essential ingredients for social change. Added to PP index Total downloads 10of 2, Recent downloads 6 months 2of 2, How can I increase my downloads? Standpoint theorists move beyond this critical moment, showing how the inclusion of lived realities, not yet properly visible to enquirers, can make for better-supported hypotheses.

For boys the central issue to be resolved concerns gender identification …. Feminisms, postcolonialities, and modernities, Raleigh: